Since its founding in 1934, 31 pastors have served in the pulpit of Brownsville Baptist Church.

Bro. James Kelly

Bro. Charles Ashcraft

Bro. Keith Babbs

Bro. E.L. Finch

Bro. Frank Norfleet

Bro. William Flynt

Bro. Horace Boyd

Bro. William Pratt

Bro. Emmitt Graham

Bro. Paul Pearson

Bro. Morris Young

Bro. Frankie Pickard

Bro. Horace Duke

Bro. Troy Carroll, Jr.

Bro. Thomas Haley

Bro. Wendell Ross

Bro. Howard Porter

Bro. Gerrald Rowe

Bro. Royce Weeks

Bro. Gene Lindsey

Bro. Royce Privett

Bro. Dave Griffin

Bro. Harold Cole

Bro. Gene Carmichael

Bro. Willie Gold

Bro. Andrew "Andy" Kerr

Bro. Darrell W. Brown

Bro. J. Roland Spears

Bro. Jody B. Jackson

Bro. Williams Duvall - interm pastor

Bro. Woody Evans